A small writing assignment which is writing a critique of a scientific paper on Natural and Sexual Selection in Wild Insect Population 

Attachment includes the article

The main guidelines for the critique are 

 1) clearly define the central research question

 2) contrast/connect different data, e.g. kind of data, interpretation, stated/unstated assumptions, etc. 

3) synthesize in a clear and insightful manner that shows  understanding of the data (what is the data, how was it collected, and presentation, assumption) 

4) show some evaluation of the content of the paper and how it aims to answer questions in a critical way

5) Should be organized in a logical order with strong introduction, good presentation of the methods and results, and  well thought out conclusions

6) Should include Primary Research Methods: Primary Findings: and Your take home message from this paper